How to Spot a Lending Scam: 9 Warning Signs for Real Estate Investors

Are you a real estate investor wondering if your lender is too good to be true? Every year, thousands of investors lose millions to scams—don’t be next. Fraudulent lenders are everywhere, and falling victim to one can completely derail your investment dreams. In this guide, we’ll uncover the 9 critical red flags that scream ‘fraudulent lender’ and provide actionable steps to protect your investments.

Stay tuned, because tip number 7 could reveal if you’ve already been scammed.

Why This Matters to You

I’ve seen real estate investors lose thousands overnight due to lending scams—let’s make sure that’s not you. Today, I’m sharing my expertise so you can spot a lending scam before it’s too late! Remember: “Fraudulent lenders prey on your hopes, but knowledge is your best defense.”

The 9 Critical Red Flags of Fraudulent Lenders

1. Suspicious Contact Information
Borrower’s view of suspicious contact information on a smartphone in a small, stylish office overlooking Salt Lake City, marked with a red 'X'.

Pay close attention to the email address and phone number used in communications. Is the lender using an email with a legitimate company domain or just a generic Gmail address? What about their phone number? Google Voice, Snapchat, or other VOIP numbers often signal potential fraud.

2. Too-Good-To-Be-True Loan Terms
Borrower’s view of suspicious contact information on a smartphone in a small, stylish office overlooking Salt Lake City, UT

When a lender quotes interest rates significantly lower than market standards or offers 100% financing when legitimate competitors max out at 70-80%, your alarm bells should ring. Remember the golden rule: if it sounds too good to be true, it probably is.

3. Suspiciously Fast Approval
"Borrower's perspective from a modest home office with a simple wooden desk and basic leather chair. A contract labeled ‘100% Financing - No Requirements’ is held in their hand. The room is decorated with minimalist decor and a framed photo of the Wasatch Mountains. The document text glows faintly to indicate deception. A red 'X' appears in the upper-right corner of the document. Bright natural light filters in through a window overlooking downtown Salt Lake City. Clean but modest setting, realistic and relatable

Legitimate lenders require substantial documentation before approving loans. If you’re getting approved almost instantly with minimal paperwork, you’re likely dealing with a scammer, not a legitimate funding source.

4. Demanding Upfront Fees

While application fees are standard in the industry, be extremely wary of large upfront payments requested before loan approval. Many investors have lost thousands by paying these “processing fees” to lenders who then disappear.

5. False Company Affiliation
orrower’s view of a cracked nameplate in a mid-range office lobby suggesting false company affiliation, marked with a red 'X'

Is this person falsely claiming to work for a reputable lending company? Take the extra step to contact the company directly through their official channels to verify the person’s employment. We’ve caught scammers pretending to work for our company when concerned borrowers called to verify.

6. Limited Online Presence
Borrower’s view of limited online presence search results from a laptop at a dining table with Salt Lake City views, marked with a red 'X'

Do thorough research using search terms that include the company name or individual’s name combined with words like “scam,” “fraud,” or “lawsuit.” Look beyond the first few search pages—fraudsters are adept at burying negative information. Be skeptical if the company only exists on a single platform like Facebook or Instagram.

7. Aggressive Pressure Tactics
Borrower’s view of aggressive lender notifications on a smartphone while sitting on a modest apartment balcony in Driggs, ID , marked with a red 'X'.

Legitimate lenders don’t desperately chase clients with incessant calls, emails, and texts. If someone is aggressively pursuing you for an upfront fee, that’s a major warning sign. Remember: you should be pursuing the lender, not the other way around.

8. Questionable Reviews
Borrower’s view of suspicious online reviews on a laptop at a shared workspace with a view of Salt Lake City, UT

Be suspicious when a lender has no reviews or only suspiciously perfect feedback. Check for genuine reviews on third-party platforms like Google and the BBB. Pay attention to specific details in reviews that indicate real transactions versus vague, generic praise.

9. Perpetual Closing Delays

The ultimate red flag often comes at the end: one excuse after another delaying your loan closing. Common tactics include key decision-makers being “unavailable,” sudden funding “issues,” or other vague excuses that persist for weeks. Once this pattern emerges, you can be certain you’re dealing with a scam.

Protect Yourself and Others

Share this information with fellow investors to help them avoid costly mistakes. Knowledge shared is an investor protected.

If you’re looking for a lender you can trust with a proven track record, reach out to me at High West Lending.


About the Author: Corey Dutton, MBA, PLM, is a private lending expert with years of experience helping real estate investors secure legitimate funding.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *